buzzfeed Press
24 Shoes That May Cost A Little Extra But Will Be *Totally* Worth It
Images
BuzzFeed and our publishing partners may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Read More Your feet are begging you to invest in some actually good shoes. I'm a deputy editorial director on the BuzzFeed Shopping team (I've been a shopping editor so long, I remember when Prime Day was just one day), who has spent the better part of a decade finding, vetting, and writing about products (and deals!), from no-nonsense toilet cleaners to the best mascaras to genius ideas that'll win your next gift exchange. Buying shoes can be tricky. Making sure they're comfortable, durable, and worth the price — that's the trifecta. Here are some reviewer-beloved and investment-worthy sneakers, boots, sandals, flats, and heels — all the pairs you need to get you through the year. And even though they might cost a bit more, you'll get a great price-per-wear, and that's just as important. Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women's. I have these sneakers in two colors (the black and white pictured above and a pair with blue accents that's not currently available), and I wear them *all the time*. They're the perfect balance of slightly chunky but not bulky, and I love the slightly retro look. And of course, they're VERY comfy. I wear them all the time walking around New York, and I brought one pair on a trip to Paris where I walked 81 miles in 8.5 days (I wore the New Balances on 7/8.5 days!), and I was comfy on every step — since then I've also brought them on three more trips! I am probably going to buy a third pair (I know...) in the linen with sea salt colorway, which is the perfect neutral. Promising review: "Fantastic! Give me one in every color! If you're on the fence, buy them. I get compliments all the time, and I'm on my feet all day. My favorite pair of New Balances to date!" —Amber B TX Get them from Amazon or New Balance for $104.95 (available in sizes 5–12 and 12 colors). Promising review: "These shoes are a favorite! I ordered the black after having a beet red color for about a year and a half. They were comfortable right out of the box, the leather is supple, and they look high quality. I am very happy with my purchase. These are often compared to the Brixton loafer from a high-end fashion brand." —Christine Get them from Amazon for $149.95 (available in sizes 4–13, in wide width, and in 45 colors and patterns). I have been LIVING in these shoes this fall. I am very (very!) sensitive to the backs of shoes, and these are totally soft and flexible, with no pesky seam to cause friction or rubbing. I've already walked miles in 'em, and know they'll be my go-tos all winter long. Promsing review: "These UGG loafers are absolutely beautiful and the most comfortable shoes I have had on my feet in years. I bought the light tan and ended up just purchasing the chestnut. I highly recommend these shoes!!!" —eyebrowfix Get them from Amazon or Nordstrom for $154.95 (available in women's sizes 5–12 and three colors). Promising review: "These heels are fabulous! Beautifully made. Stylish. Most importantly—- comfortable! Probably the most comfortable heels I've ever worn. At a black tie event for 8 hours and was amazed that my feet were not aching and sore (after standing\dancing for at least 6 of those 8). The heel is the perfect size to remain stable (no wobbling or ankle twisting). Love these!!!" —G. Get them from Amazon for $139.95 (available in sizes 4–12, including narrow, wide, and extra wide, and over 30 colors/styles). Here's BuzzFeed Shopping editor Jenae Sitzes: Reviewers swear these don't even have a break-in period, making them a great pickup for that last-minute outdoorsy trip where hiking and rough terrain are on the docket. Note that it's recommended to go up a half size in these boots to accommodate thicker hiking socks, and I found that to be true when I picked up these shoes myself — I'm normally an 8 but found an 8.5 in these to be totally comfortable. I also found that they hold up well even on my first hike — though I did admittedly still have some soreness around my heel area, this was after a hard, 7+-mile hike with lots of rocks and climbing, so I don't blame the shoes. They felt comfortable right out of the box and super supportive when I was clamoring over rocks and rough terrain. And though I only stepped in water a couple of times briefly, my socks stayed dry, too. I got the brown color with red laces as pictured above, and they're even cuter in person, which is just another plus. Promising review: "I use these for hiking and work. So I originally got these a while back for hiking alone, but my ankles are prone to sprains. These are amazing at supporting the ankle, they feel decently comfortable (I add additional insoles to cushion the heel), and are incredibly sturdy. I've killed two other day-shoes in the time that I've had these. I can also attest that at work, when a bin of water was dumped on them, they are indeed waterproof! Do they look a little beat up? Yes. But they definitely are worth the price. They fit well, don't need too much breaking in, and aside from being hot in the summer, are a shoe I'd love to put more milage on for years to come." —Sarah Get them from Amazon for $110 (available in sizes 5–12, including wide sizes, and 16 colors). You can find a similar men's version here. Promising review: "Thank you to all the lovely people who left reviews for these boots. There’s literally nothing I would change about them - they’re perfect. So comfortable and they make my feet look beautiful. I bought the chocolate suede pair, and if I could afford it, I’d get the burgundy leather ones too. —Alexandra D. Get them Everlane for $288 (available in sizes 5–11 and three colors and styles). Promising review: "Buy them! Perfect leather boot! Great quality, walkable heel, perfect height, which I love. You won’t go wrong. In fact, I bought them in suede as well. Looks great with jeans and dress pants." —Amazon Customer Get it from Amazon for $109.99+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide sizes, and seven colors/styles). Here's one TikToker calling these one of their "most-worn pieces of 2026." Promising review: "I feel like the true test of how much I like something is whether or not I would buy it again. And I would totally buy these again. They are comfortable out of the box. In fact, I wore them that same day, and walked 6000 steps, without socks, whilst at the beach promenade (paved, but hilly!, and wooden boardwalk). No blisters, no chafing. The footbed is lightly padded, the woven leather is soft. A plus that it matches the woven bag too ;)" —Jacinda Get them from Quince for $84 (available in sizes 5–10 and six colors). Promising review: "These are the most wonderful shoes on earth. They are my go-to for shoes. I've been wearing them for 7 years now, and I love them as much now as when I first purchased them." —DEBRA S. Get them from Rothy's for $165 (available in sizes 5–13 and in 34 colors and patterns). You can also get select colors from Amazon. Promising review: "I'm in love with these! Not only do I love how they look, but I also love how they feel! I walk 5 miles 6 days a week, and these give my feet enough cushion and enough room! My old pair continued to give me blisters and rub the back of my heel. I will not have any of those issues with these. I'm very impressed." —Britt J. Promising review: "I rarely ever write reviews, but these shoes literally feel like walking on pillows. I always waste money trying to find comfy shoes, and I thought this would be another one of those times, but I am pleasantly surprised! I haven't experienced foot pain all day. I'm on my feet 10 hours a day as I commute to work in NYC and work 8 hours a day. if you work in healthcare, these are a MUST!" —Celebrity Cooper Get them from Amazon for $65 (available in sizes 5–11 and eight colors). Thursday Boot Company suggests ordering a half size up from your normal size (aka your boot size). Promising review: "I’ve bought from Thursday in the past, and I always love their boots and get so many compliments. They’re well-made and go with everything. They’re definitely worth the price. I’ve had some pairs for years, and they hold up in every kind of weather! 10/10 recommend!" —Amazon Customer Get them from Amazon for $160 (available in sizes 5–11 and in 10 colors). And you can swap the laces out between regular and satin (picured above) to suit your style — both are included. Promising review: "I probably wear these boots at least five times a week I absolutely love them. The only thing I can say is you're going to need to put something in the heel to lift your foot up because the back will rub your heel and you will end up with blisters. I made the mistake when I first got them, but once I got the Dr Scholl's heel inserts, it was perfect, and I have never looked back. I love these shoes. I love the little height that it gives me. I love how they feel when I walk. I just cannot say one bad thing about these boots; they are a great, great investment and really worth the money." —Steph Get them from Amazon for $209.99 (available in sizes 5–11). Promising review: "I normally don't like wearing tennis shoes all day because my feet tend to sweat in them, then swell when I take them off. These are the best brand of tennis shoes I have ever owned. They feel wonderful on my arthritic feet, and my feet breathe in them all day, so they never sweat and don't swell up when I take them off. I bought a second pair in white. Well worth the money. All my other tennis shoes are going to Goodwill." —SBoo Get them from Amazon for $145 (available in sizes 5–12 and 22 styles). Promising review: "These are the cutest sweetest little shoes that I get the most compliments on. Not only are they eye-catching, but they are so comfortable, easy to slip on and wear throughout the day. I want a pair of every design! My newest obsession." —Mary L. Get them from Vivaia for $139 (available in sizes 5–11 and 22 colors/styles). Promising review: "Beautiful sneaker, very much a casual chic look. The full-grain leather looks and feels very high quality, and they're very much a 'go with everything' shoe. Most importantly, they're incredibly comfortable. I've walked long distances in them with absolutely no issues at all. Highly recommend." —Francisco P. Get them from Quince for $100 (available in sizes 5–12 and four colors). Promising review: "This is the first pair of heels that I have been able to wear in 5 years! I had very extensive surgery on my right foot; yet, these fit the bill! Happy feet!!!!!" —Sandra W. Get them from Vivaia for $159 (available in sizes 5–11 and in black and nude. Also available in a version without the crossover strap, in regular, kitten, and stiletto heels). Promising review: "This is my third pair of Everlane Day Glove shoes, and I will probably get more. As someone who suffers from foot problems, I was sold after the first pair! I was able to put them on and go with no problems. The soft leather truly conforms to my feet." —TN Mimi Get them from Everlane for $98 (available in sizes 5–11 and in nine colors). Here's BuzzFeed Shopping contributor Rachelle Yang: "I had these bbs for three years but had to say goodbye to them because it was finally their time to go. 🥲 I first got these shoes because I have very weak ankles and needed shoes that would support them, but these did waaaay more than that. The platforms were a lot comfier than I thought they were going to be, and I wore these EVERYWHERE. From concerts to hikes to beaches, these bad boys really put in the work and held up through everything. I never had a moment when I felt uncomfy with these on, and besides all that, they're SO SO SO cute!!!" Promising review: "The most comfortable sneakers I own! I have a high arch and need the platform style for comfort. Love the look and the price." —Shelby R Get them from Amazon or Converse (available in sizes 5–12 and in four colors, plus a make-your-own if you order at Converse). Promising review: "The best shoes I've ever worn. These shoes are a lifesaver! I'm on my feet for 10-hour shifts, and HOKAs keep me comfortable the whole time. Super cushioned, lightweight, and supportive; totally worth the money." —Nancy Get them from Hoka for $175 (available in sizes 5–12 and in 21 colors). Promising review: "Love these boots, they fit perfectly. Took two weeks to wear in, and since then, I have been incredibly comfortable. I have lupus and lots of foot issues, including plantar fasciitis and arthritis, and they are very comfortable." —Karen Get them from DuoBoots for $238 (originally $340; available in sizes 5—12 and in eight calf widths; also available in black leather). Promising review: "Living in Michigan, I need boots that can handle 4–5 months of ice, slush, and deep snow. These Sorel Snow Angels are exactly what I was looking for. Not only are they incredibly cute, but they are also a powerhouse in winter weather, and there was no break-in period. I was thrilled to find that these are true to size. I ordered my regular shoe size, and they fit perfectly - even when I’m wearing thick wool socks. There is enough room for comfort without feeling loose or clunky. The bottoms are made of a thick, sturdy material that provides a great barrier against the freezing ground. My feet stay warm and dry, even when walking through icy slush. They feel very durable and well-insulated. It’s rare to find a boot that is this functional while still being so stylish. They have a great silhouette that looks good with leggings or snow pants. I think these were good value for the money — hoping they last for years to come!" —Sara Get them from Amazon for $140 (available in sizes 5–11 and in four colors). Promising review: "These are THE booties in my wardrobe. They carry me all through fall and winter. I would have kept my last pair longer, but my cat ate holes in them. They're a great ankle height for me, keep me warm when I wear them with socks, and are just an all-around staple piece. Dress them up or dress them down, they're ready for anything." —Lisa V Get them from Amazon for $99.99+ (available in sizes 5–13, including wide widths, and 61 colors and fabric styles). Reviewers note to buy these in a size up from your usual shoe size! Promising review: "Love these shoes! I saw them in store at Urban Outfitters, but they didn't have my size. Obviously, I turned to Amazon because what doesn’t this site sell, and lo and behold, y’all had it. I try to pair these with almost every outfit because they’re so comfy and stylish! Recently went to Philly, where I had to walk everywhere because we didn't rent a car and these were the only pair of shoes I brought (I travel light). These didn’t cramp up my feet at all as I walked over seven hours daily over the course of five days. Definitely recommend!" —Alli J Get them from Amazon for $60.14+ (available in sizes 5–11 and three styles). Ma’am Shoes is a woman-owned small business creating beautiful and comfortable shoes you can wear for years. If you are in between sizes, the brand recommends you size up. Promising review: "The first day of wear can typically be a challenge for new shoes because I work long hours and am on my feet all day. I am thrilled to report that they wear wonderfully — they felt like I already owned them for a month — they were that comfortable! 10s across the board in my book. I sized 1/2 size up and am so glad I did. Definitely buying more soon." —Ashley Cornett Get them from Ma'am Shoes for $300 (originally $350; available in sizes 5–11). * Pairs Of Shoes Reviewers With Bunions, Plantar Fasciitis, And Other Foot-Related Issues Swear By * Cute Non-High-Heel Shoes To Wear With Dresses * Boots That Reviewers Say Were Comfy Right Away * Pairs Of Shoes People Who Stand All Day At Work Swear By * Pairs Of Shoes That You’ll Wear So Much, They’ll Have A Designated Place Of Honor At Your Front Door Plus, rain boots, and finds from Amazon, Clarks, DSW, Nordstrom, and Zappos. BuzzFeed Shopping is service journalism first: our writers and editors spend all day shopping so you don’t have to, vetting products, fact-checking brand claims, and surfacing what actually helps in real life. We center readers over revenue, recommend products with authenticity (using real experiences, not ad-speak), and reflect our diverse audience, inclusive of a variety of price points, people, and needs. We cut through fake deals, favor useful info over glossy fluff, and recommend both budget and splurge options with context so you can decide what’s right for you — and still have a little fun along the way. The reviews in this post have been edited for length and clarity.
Comments
You must be logged in to comment.