Turns out stale bread from a box can be delicious.

Luke is a writer and actor based in Philadelphia who loves deviled eggs and elaborate food adventures.

We measured the required amount of boiling water from the big pot and mixed it into the butter for each stuffing.

The numbers correspond to numbers written on the now-empty packages.

It's hard to apply the word "splurge" to boxed stuffing that costs, on average, $3.25. Kooshy ultimately costs 66 cents per ounce, making it the second-most expensive brand. But for a brand that I had never even heard of before, we were all pretty impressed.ย 

It's clearly positioning itself as a more "organic" option, yet still delivers on both flavor and texture. It was a little bit dry compared to some of the others, but we could possibly chalk that up to a preparation error. I think it's worth giving this a shot.

Very rarely do you expect the generic brand to take down some of the big hitters, but this scored better than almost every other stuffing. It had the most herb flavor, the right amount of moistness, and at 29 cents an ounce, it's far and away the best value on the market.ย 

We scientists had a discussion about whether the contents of this box were the same as our number one overall repackaged as its own brand. (We obviously can't confirm, but I suppose it's possible.) Whatever the case, this stuffing slaps.

Much like when Swiss Miss won the hot chocolate mix taste test, the oldest brand in the contest takes the top prize. Stove Top has had nearly 55 years to perfect its recipe, and the scoring proves it. This stuffing earned three first-place votes (and my misguided sixth-place vote; I had the leftovers for lunch the following day, and I would amend my selection to at least third).ย 

I think if you amplified Stove Top with some onions and celery, you'd be hard-pressed to tell the difference between it and a homemade version. Compared to some other brands that tasted like wet cardboard, Stove Top is chock-full of herbs and spices. Also, the texture and moistness were spot on. If you're going with a boxed stuffing at this year's feast, Stove Top is the way to go.