“Everyone LOVES that book, and I just want to know if we read the same thing.”

I'm an Assignment Editor at BuzzFeed, which means I primarily spend my days ideating, editing, and mentoring our wonderful team of freelancers.

Additional responses were found in this Reddit thread.

"I read it in my sophomore year of high school, and our whole class loved it so much, except me. I was like, 'Holden is insufferable and makes his past traumas everyone else's problem; what about this do y'all love so much?' 

To this day, I'm still wondering what the rest of my English class saw in that book other than possibly the compelling way our teacher read it out loud."

"It's a different kind of classic, I suppose, because I didn't find it beautifully written. Maybe a classic bore or a classic waste of a read."

"This is an excellent review, even if my melodramatic ass loves The Scarlet Letter."

"It took me three months to get past the first chapter, which I had to do, because it was required reading for school."

"So glad to see people saying The Great Gatsby. I cannot understand the love for this book. 

Having been assigned it three times — once in high school and twice in college — I just do not see why it's considered the 'quintessential American novel.'"

"1984 is a dull read. The underpinning ideas are riveting, but it is a tough read. Orwell's essays in general are excellent, however, and Animal Farm is a fun read."

"The Alchemist makes The Da Vinci Code seem profound. Not a compliment to either book."

"I found the pacing bizarre and felt really bored most of the time. 

The last 200 pages were a slog. Also, just in general, I had trouble following what was going on."

"My nemesis in book form is The Old Man and the Sea. Everyone LOVES that book, and I just want to know if we read the same thing. 

Beyond boring, it aggravated me beyond belief, and you feel every one of its 127 pages. Just brutal, and seeing it on the shelf makes me rage."

"I tried multiple times to read it and couldn't get past the second page. Ugh."

"I get the scope. I get the message. I even get the writing, and I used to be fluent enough to have read some of it in French (I’d already read it in English and hadn’t been impressed; I wanted to make sure it wasn’t the translation). It’s all good. I have to praise him as I should.

But Jesus on a pony, why didn’t anyone edit that damn doorstop?"

Note: Some responses have been edited for length and/or clarity.